Each is 3.5”. The non-smiling button has tiny raised bump to the right of his head caused by the reverse bar pin and this has taken on a tiny darker dot of color. Otherwise just some normal surface wear in reflected light. Still with high gloss. Second item with him in a broad smile is totally clean but colors are not as deep and intense as on the preceding button. No stain. The first is Hake #2010 and second is Hake #2011.